New Law on Religion: Point/Counterpoint
The controversial new law on religion which passed Parliament is waiting for the President’s signature. The law will outlaw unregistered religious activity, and increase the requirements for registering religions. It also appears to exclude small religious groups and mandates government approval of all religious texts. The law is clearly created defensively to prevent cult-like activity or terrorist cells from working in the country. However it effectively criminalizes religion by demanding that religions prove themselves innocent before being allowed to work. There have also been allegations that provisions of the law have already been enforced (even though the law has not passed yet) in order to take valuable land away from religious groups.
This at least is what most people seem to be saying about this new law On Religion. For a fuller treatment of the law and some of the controversies, check Forum 18’s article: KAZAKHSTAN: “We will wait until after the New Year, and then seize his property”
However, today I got a bulletin from the Kazakhstan Embassy to the US, defending the law. Since it as yet does not appear to be online anywhere, I thought I would publish it here so it could be more widely spread [If anyone from the Embassy objects to my posting the article, please let me know and I will take it down immediately].
On the whole, the article is not convincing. First of all, it is true that many ethnicities and religions live side-by-side in Kazakhstan and that certainly Kazakhstan does much better on the front of interethnic or interreligious tolerance than any other country in the CIS or many countries in the world. However the claim that there has never been any violence due to religious or ethnic conflict is not supportable, except for the fact that it is illegal to call anything in Kazakhstan an ethnic conflict. Therefore officially there has never been ethnic conflict and never will be.
While the Embassy invokes 9/11, the list of insensitivities (a word that itself is rather mild) in Kazakhstan are pretty lame. (more…)



